ONC's "21st Century Cures Act" Misses the Mark on Encryption
March 12, 2019 •Walt Paley
A month ago, ONC shared a draft of the "21st Century Cures Act" in advance of the public comment period. I responded on Twitter with concerns about their peculiar stance on encryption.
Now the public comment portal is open, and I encourage you to add your voice to the conversation!
My comment:
Regarding
IV. Updates to the 2015 Edition Certification Criteria
B. Revised and New 2015 Edition Criteria
6. Privacy and Security Transparency Attestations Criteria
b. Encrypt Authentication CredentialsSelf-attestation to be "capable" of encrypting to FIPS 140-2 cryptographic standards is not enough and not aligned with the intention of NIST's cryptographic benchmarking program. Validation of FIPS 140-2 encryption standards via NIST has evolved and is no longer a prohibitive process. There is no reason that it should not be an explicit requirement, just as it is for every other federal agency. The HITECH Act and other healthcare legislation has consistently referred all cryptographic requirements to NIST, referencing FIPS 140-2 validation. Even in this very proposed rule, it states that "We posit that FIPS Publication 140-2 is the seminal, comprehensive, and most appropriate standard." And yet, the rule pivots to "self-attestation" instead of enforcing the very benchmarking test that FIPS 140-2 itself was written to make explicit.
Self-attestation of "capability" means nothing. The FIPS 140-2 standard says that any encryption not tested and validated to meet the standard is considered to be no better than plaintext. Self-attestation would fall squarely into that bucket.
Again, please weigh in on the "21st Century Cures Act", whether specific to encryption or otherwise. While I'm focused on the contradictory stance they have proposed, to reference but not actually follow FIPS 140-2, it's critically important for all points of view to be represented. The deadline is Friday, May 3, 2019 at 11:59 PM Eastern. I also welcome dialogue on Twitter!

Walt Paley
Walter Paley is the VP of Communications for SafeLogic. He is responsible for strategy, content, marketing, and outreach. Walt has worked with a series of start-ups and companies in growth stages, including Nukona (acquired by Symantec), Qubole, Bitzer Mobile (acquired by Oracle), and TigerText, among others. An Alumnus of the psychology program at UC San Diego, Walt lives in Southern California with his wife, kids, and their black lab, Echo.
Popular Posts
Search for posts
Tags
- FIPS 140 (102)
- FIPS validation (83)
- Encryption (68)
- cryptography (63)
- NIST (60)
- CryptoComply (58)
- SafeLogic (58)
- Industry News (54)
- cryptographic module (51)
- Conversations (49)
- CMVP (48)
- RapidCert (46)
- compliance (39)
- Ray Potter (33)
- SafeLogic News (33)
- Event (27)
- federal (27)
- CAVP (23)
- Cybersecurity (22)
- algorithm (22)
- #LoveOurCustomers (15)
- OpenSSL (14)
- government (14)
- CryptoCompact (13)
- Cryptology (12)
- DoD (12)
- FedRAMP (12)
- RSA (12)
- compatible (12)
- partners (12)
- NSA (11)
- healthcare (11)
- AES (9)
- Apple (9)
- Cloud (9)
- FIPS 140-3 (9)
- Wearable (9)
- award (9)
- health (9)
- security (9)
- time (9)
- HIPAA (8)
- Homeland Security (8)
- IoT (8)
- Suite B (8)
- hack (8)
- testing (8)
- whitepaper (8)
- CMMC (7)
- agency (7)
- client (7)
- constrained devices (7)
- Advisories (6)
- Approved Products List (APL) (6)
- HITECH (6)
- holiday (6)
- lab (6)
- vulnerability (6)
- Acumen (5)
- CEO (5)
- Dual EC DRBG (5)
- Google (5)
- Google Glass (5)
- ICMC (5)
- Microsoft (5)
- NIST 800-171 (5)
- NIST 800-53 (5)
- OpenSSL 3.0 (5)
- Safe Harbor (5)
- Wes Higaki (5)
- Whit Diffie (5)
- ePHI (5)
- healthIT (5)
- heartbleed (5)
- mHealth (5)
- procurement (5)
- vulnerable (5)
- C3PAO (4)
- HHS (4)
- HITECH Act (4)
- Mark Minnoch (4)
- Samsung (4)
- Vegas (4)
- archive (4)
- attack (4)
- blog (4)
- breach (4)
- breaches (4)
- deadline (4)
- encrypt (4)
- health IT (4)
- innovation (4)
- military (4)
- procure (4)
- AFCEA (3)
- Air Force (3)
- BSAFE (3)
- BouncyCastle (3)
- CSE (3)
- Common Criteria (3)
- DFARS (3)
- DISA (3)
- EMM (3)
- FIPS 186 (3)
- FIPS-approved (3)
- HIMSS (3)
- HIPAA Safe Harbor (3)
- HITECH Safe Harbor (3)
- Heartbleed Bug (3)
- Implementation Guidance (3)
- Implementation Under Testing (3)
- InfoSec (3)
- NVLAP (3)
- National Institute of Standards and Technology (3)
- New Year (3)
- OCR (3)
- OpenSSL 1.1.1 (3)
- PHI (3)
- POA&M (3)
- Snowden (3)
- advisor (3)
- blackberry (3)
- budget (3)
- bug (3)
- competition (3)
- connected (3)
- constrained (3)
- data at rest (3)
- editorial (3)
- forum (3)
- goals (3)
- healthcare IT (3)
- iPhone (3)
- liberty (3)
- magazine (3)
- open source (3)
- patriotic (3)
- privacy (3)
- public sector (3)
- queue (3)
- revalidation (3)
- software (3)
- speaking (3)
- transition (3)
- vulnerabilities (3)
- 3PAO (2)
- ACVP (2)
- BA (2)
- BAA (2)
- CIO (2)
- CSEC (2)
- CSP (2)
- CoIT (2)
- Coalfire (2)
- Cyber Defense Magazine (2)
- Cyberattack (2)
- DIY (2)
- Defense Industrial Base (2)
- Diffie-Hellman (2)
- ECDH (2)
- EHR (2)
- FBI (2)
- FIPS 197 (2)
- FIPS 199 (2)
- FIPS ready (2)
- Facebook (2)
- FinalCode (2)
- Firefox (2)
- Forbes (2)
- HIPAA security controls (2)
- Historical (2)
- Historical Status (2)
- IPsec (2)
- IPsec VPN (2)
- Java (2)
- Jawbone (2)
- Jawbone Up (2)
- Level 1 (2)
- Level 2 (2)
- Level 3 (2)
- Level 4 (2)
- MFA (2)
- MSFT (2)
- Maribel Lopez (2)
- Marine Corps (2)
- Marines (2)
- Mark (2)
- Marquess (2)
- Module in Process (2)
- Mozilla (2)
- NIST 800-111 (2)
- NIST 800-38 (2)
- NSS (2)
- Naughty List (2)
- Navy (2)
- Nest (2)
- Nest thermostat (2)
- Network Security Services (2)
- OpenSSL 1.0.2 (2)
- Pentagon (2)
- Poodle (2)
- President (2)
- RNG (2)
- RSA BSAFE (2)
- RSA Security (2)
- SHA (2)
- SPRS (2)
- SSL (2)
- SSL VPN (2)
- Samsung Galaxy Gear (2)
- San Francisco (2)
- Securonix (2)
- Silicon Valley (2)
- Smart Fridge (2)
- Steve Marquess (2)
- Suite A (2)
- TLS (2)
- TLS 1.3 (2)
- U.S. (2)
- U.S. Armed Forces (2)
- UK (2)
- US (2)
- US Armed Forces (2)
- USA (2)
- Up (2)
- VPN (2)
- Walt Paley (2)
- Webinar (2)
- Wired (2)
- accelerate (2)
- achieving safe harbor (2)
- achieving safe harbor in healthcare (2)
- acquisition (2)
- archive list (2)
- armed forces (2)
- article (2)
- backdoor (2)
- benchmark (2)
- breach notification (2)
- business associate (2)
- business associate agreement (2)
- case study (2)
- checkmark (2)
- code (2)
- competitor (2)
- constrained device (2)
- consultant (2)
- consultants (2)
- consulting (2)
- cost (2)
- cyber terrorism (2)
- data in motion (2)
- developer (2)
- doctor (2)
- entropy (2)
- excellence (2)
- fast (2)
- federal acquisition (2)
- federal procurement (2)
- federal shutdown (2)
- finance (2)
- firmware (2)
- founder (2)
- freedom (2)
- goal (2)
- gold (2)
- guest (2)
- hardware (2)
- hurdle (2)
- hybrid (2)
- iOS 6 (2)
- key management (2)
- leader (2)
- legacy (2)
- mandate (2)
- maturity (2)
- medal (2)
- overlap (2)
- patch (2)
- patches (2)
- patient (2)
- penalties (2)
- pilot (2)
- post-quantum cryptography (2)
- re-validation (2)
- regulated industry (2)
- research (2)
- rival (2)
- security breach (2)
- session (2)
- shutdown (2)
- solution (2)
- speed (2)
- sponsors (2)
- startup (2)
- sunset (2)
- support (2)
- team (2)
- technology (2)
- terrorism (2)
- terrorist (2)
- use case (2)
- vendor (2)
- year (2)
- year end (2)
- (ISC)2 (1)
- 21st Century Cures Act (1)
- Active Status (1)
- Alliance for Digital Innovation (1)
- Amazon (1)
- Android (1)
- Army (1)
- BYOD (1)
- Boeing (1)
- Brent Cook (1)
- Bruce Schneier (1)
- CCEVS (1)
- CES (1)
- CIO Prime Views (1)
- CIO Story (1)
- CIOstory (1)
- CNET (1)
- CNN (1)
- CNSA (1)
- CNSS (1)
- COTS (1)
- CSF (1)
- CTR_DRBG (1)
- CUI (1)
- Cameron (1)
- Chris Conlon (1)
- Columbia University (1)
- Commercial Solutions for Classified (1)
- Cryptographic Technology Group (1)
- Cryptsoft (1)
- CsfC (1)
- Cupertino (1)
- Cyber Monday (1)
- D-FLIP (1)
- DEA (1)
- DES (1)
- DHS (1)
- DIU (1)
- DIUx (1)
- DNA (1)
- DOJ (1)
- Daniel Franke (1)
- David Cameron (1)
- David Hook (1)
- EPCS (1)
- Erlich Bachman (1)
- Extended Support (1)
- FCA (1)
- FF1 (1)
- FF3 (1)
- FIPS Compliance (1)
- FISMA (1)
- FITARA (1)
- FOM (1)
- FOM 2.0 (1)
- FPE (1)
- FUD (1)
- False Claims Act (1)
- Fear and Loathing (1)
- Fed (1)
- Federal IT Sales Summit (1)
- Fitbit (1)
- Florida (1)
- Forbes Magazine (1)
- Fourth of July (1)
- Frank McDonough (1)
- G.18 (1)
- GCHQ (1)
- GNU (1)
- GNU Project (1)
- GSA (1)
- Galaxy (1)
- Galaxy Gear (1)
- Gartner (1)
- Gartner Symposium (1)
- Gavin Belson (1)
- Globo (1)
- GnuPG (1)
- GoBe (1)
- Golden Globes (1)
- Govie (1)
- Govies (1)
- Grammy (1)
- Grammys (1)
- HASH_DRBG (1)
- HBO (1)
- HIIPA (1)
- HIPPA (1)
- HIT (1)
- HITRUST (1)
- HITRUST CSF (1)
- HMAC (1)
- HMAC_DRBG (1)
- HUD (1)
- Healbe (1)
- Heartbeat (1)
- Hebdo (1)
- Hooli (1)
- Hummer (1)
- Humvee (1)
- Hunter S. Thompson (1)
- IBM (1)
- ICMC 2013 (1)
- ICS (1)
- ICS-ISAC (1)
- IPB (1)
- ISO (1)
- ISO 19790 (1)
- ISO 24759 (1)
- ITexpo (1)
- ITexpo West (1)
- ITexpo West 2014 (1)
- Immix (1)
- In Progress (1)
- In Progress List (1)
- Inauguration (1)
- Industrial Control System (1)
- Infogard (1)
- Intel (1)
- Investigatory Powers Bill (1)
- Iron Mountain (1)
- JAR (1)
- JCE (1)
- JITC (1)
- JLTV (1)
- JSSE (1)
- Jack Barker (1)
- Jawbone Up24 (1)
- Joint Light Tactical Vehicles (1)
- KAS (1)
- KBKDF (1)
- Kamala Harris (1)
- Katie Arrington (1)
- Kestler (1)
- Kris van Riper (1)
- LRSB (1)
- Lee (1)
- Lee Kestler (1)
- Legacy List (1)
- Legacy Validation List (1)
- Legion (1)
- LibreSSL (1)
- LinkedIn (1)
- Linux (1)
- Lockheed (1)
- Lockheed Martin (1)
- Lopez Research (1)
- MDMPP (1)
- MDPP (1)
- MIT (1)
- MWC (1)
- Macintosh (1)
- Marissa Mayer (1)
- Mark Amtower (1)
- Matt Caswell (1)
- Matt Cornelius (1)
- Matthew Cornelius (1)
- Matthew Green (1)
- Maturity Model (1)
- Memorial Day (1)
- Michael Leonard (1)
- MicroStrategy (1)
- Microsoft Surface (1)
- Miramar (1)
- Multifactor (1)
- NCSL (1)
- NSA Suite B (1)
- Nevada (1)
- Nike+ (1)
- Nobel (1)
- North Korea (1)
- Northrup (1)
- Northrup Grumman (1)
- OCS (1)
- OMB (1)
- ONC (1)
- OSL (1)
- OSSL 1.1 (1)
- OSSL Foundation (1)
- OVS (1)
- Office 365 (1)
- Oracle (1)
- Orlando (1)
- Oscars (1)
- Osh Kosh (1)
- Oshkosh (1)
- Outlook (1)
- Oval Office (1)
- P-256 (1)
- P-384 (1)
- PC Mag (1)
- PCI (1)
- PCI-DSS (1)
- PIN (1)
- PIN code (1)
- PIN number (1)
- PM (1)
- PQC (1)
- PRISM (1)
- Padding Oracle On Downgraded Legacy Encryption (1)
- Palazzo (1)
- Palo Alto (1)
- Paris (1)
- Pence (1)
- Pied Piper (1)
- Pilgrims (1)
- Poison (1)
- Poodlebleed (1)
- Presidency (1)
- Prime Minister (1)
- Prius (1)
- Protection Profiles (1)
- Pulse Secure (1)
- Q4 (1)
- Quantum Dawn (1)
- Quest (1)
- RAR (1)
- REDCOM (1)
- RFP (1)
- Ralph C. Jensen (1)
- Ralph Jensen (1)
- Raytheon (1)
- Readiness Assessment Report (1)
- Rebranding (1)
- Redmond (1)
- Richard Hendricks (1)
- Rijndael (1)
- Rohit Sethi (1)
- Ryan Thomas (1)
- SC Magazine (1)
- SC-13 (1)
- SC-28 (1)
- SC-8 (1)
- SLED (1)
- SP (1)
- SP 800-113 (1)
- SP 800-56 (1)
- SP 800-77 (1)
- SP800-131A (1)
- SP800-90A (1)
- SSLv3 (1)
- Samsung Galaxy (1)
- Sands (1)
- Sands Expo (1)
- Satcom (1)
- Schneier (1)
- Sean Kerner (1)
- SecureAuth (1)
- Security B-Sides (1)
- Security Compass (1)
- SecurityToday (1)
- September 22 (1)
- Sergey Brin (1)
- Seth Rosenblatt (1)
- Sethi (1)
- Signal Magazine (1)
- Simon (1)
- Skipjack (1)
- Skunk Works (1)
- Skunkworks (1)
- Skydrive (1)
- Snooper's Charter (1)
- Softshell (1)
- Sony (1)
- Speck (1)
- Squanto (1)
- St Regis (1)
- StateRAMP (1)
- Steve Jobs (1)
- Surface (1)
- Susan McAndrew (1)
- Sweet32 (1)
- Symantec (1)
- TLS 1.1 (1)
- TLS 1.2 (1)
- TSMC (1)
- Taming the Transition (1)
- Taming the Transition: Marketing & Sales Tacti (1)
- Tanuj Gulati (1)
- Target (1)
- Target breach (1)
- Tesla (1)
- Theresa May (1)
- Thomas (1)
- Tim Hudson (1)
- Tisquantum (1)
- Tizen (1)
- Tom Cruise (1)
- Toyota (1)
- Toyota Prius (1)
- Triple DES (1)
- Trump (1)
- U.K. (1)
- U.S. Air Force (1)
- U.S. Army (1)
- U.S. Marines (1)
- U.S. Military (1)
- U.S. Navy (1)
- US Air Force (1)
- US Army (1)
- US Marines (1)
- US Military (1)
- US Navy (1)
- USMC (1)
- United Kingdom (1)
- United States (1)
- United States of America (1)
- Up24 (1)
- Vectra (1)
- Vectra Networks (1)
- Venetian (1)
- Verify (1)
- WEST (1)
- WEST 2020 (1)
- Wall Street (1)
- Weaved (1)
- Websense (1)
- WhatsApp (1)
- White House (1)
- Wiebe (1)
- Wired.co.uk (1)
- Wireless U (1)
- WolfSSL (1)
- Yahoo (1)
- Yier Jin (1)
- Yoics (1)
- You're fired! (1)
- Yubico (1)
- abbreviation (1)
- abbreviations (1)
- achieve (1)
- acronym (1)
- acronyms (1)
- administration (1)
- advantage (1)
- appointee (1)
- archival (1)
- assurance (1)
- authentication (1)
- autumn (1)
- aviation (1)
- background (1)
- ban (1)
- banish (1)
- banished (1)
- banishment (1)
- banned (1)
- batterygate (1)
- benchmarks (1)
- best (1)
- bid (1)
- blue angel (1)
- blue angels (1)
- bold (1)
- browser (1)
- bugs (1)
- calendar (1)
- capitol (1)
- certicom (1)
- challenge (1)
- champ (1)
- champion (1)
- channel (1)
- checklist (1)
- checkmarks (1)
- chief (1)
- chip (1)
- chipgate (1)
- choice (1)
- choose (1)
- chosen (1)
- cipher (1)
- citizen (1)
- citizenship (1)
- co-founder (1)
- codebase (1)
- codies (1)
- comment period (1)
- comparison (1)
- compete (1)
- competitive (1)
- competitive advantage (1)
- complaint (1)
- complaints (1)
- complete (1)
- concurrent (1)
- confusion (1)
- congress (1)
- contract (1)
- crime (1)
- criminal (1)
- critical infrastructure (1)
- cryptographer (1)
- cybertech (1)
- data (1)
- data center (1)
- data centers (1)
- data security (1)
- dates (1)
- david hume (1)
- debt ceiling (1)
- decryption (1)
- deploy (1)
- deployment (1)
- development (1)
- dictionary (1)
- differentiator (1)
- disambiguate (1)
- download (1)
- drones (1)
- eBay (1)
- eBay breach (1)
- eHealth (1)
- eWeek (1)
- editor (1)
- editor-in-chief (1)
- effort (1)
- elliptic curve cryptography (1)
- embedded (1)
- emerging (1)
- engineer (1)
- engineering (1)
- enterprise security (1)
- executive (1)
- exhibit (1)
- exhibit hall (1)
- expectations (1)
- expert (1)
- expertise (1)
- experts (1)
- expiration (1)
- expire (1)
- extended (1)
- fall (1)
- faq (1)
- finalist (1)
- finalists (1)
- financial (1)
- fines (1)
- fintech (1)
- fips inside (1)
- fiscal (1)
- fiscal year (1)
- fitness tracker (1)
- fitness trackers (1)
- fix (1)
- fixes (1)
- flight (1)
- forecast (1)
- format-preserving (1)
- format-preserving encryption (1)
- fraud (1)
- frempetitor (1)
- frempetitors (1)
- frenemies (1)
- frenemy (1)
- furlough (1)
- future (1)
- global (1)
- globee (1)
- glossary (1)
- goose (1)
- gotcha (1)
- gov (1)
- gov't (1)
- guest blog (1)
- guest post (1)
- hashed (1)
- head-to-head (1)
- heads up displays (1)
- hill (1)
- hiring freeze (1)
- history (1)
- home automation (1)
- homeland (1)
- honor (1)
- honored (1)
- hospital (1)
- human rights (1)
- hume (1)
- humor (1)
- hurdles (1)
- iMessage (1)
- iOS (1)
- iOS 7 (1)
- iPad (1)
- iToilet (1)
- industry (1)
- intellectual property (1)
- interim final rule (1)
- international (1)
- interview (1)
- issues (1)
- kratos (1)
- launch (1)
- law enforcement (1)
- libgcrypt (1)
- malicious (1)
- maverick (1)
- medals (1)
- medical (1)
- medicine (1)
- meek (1)
- milestone (1)
- mobile security (1)
- mobility (1)
- mocana (1)
- money (1)
- multi-factor (1)
- multi-factor authentication (1)
- musings (1)
- national cybersecurity strategy (1)
- naval aviator (1)
- need for speed (1)
- neglect (1)
- network (1)
- new (1)
- new OSSL (1)
- news (1)
- nominate (1)
- nominated (1)
- nominee (1)
- nominees (1)
- offload (1)
- opportunities (1)
- opportunity (1)
- outsource (1)
- panel (1)
- parallel (1)
- passwords (1)
- past (1)
- patient data (1)
- philosopher (1)
- philosophy (1)
- physician (1)
- piece (1)
- pilots (1)
- plane (1)
- plans (1)
- platinum (1)
- post (1)
- presentation (1)
- press release (1)
- priorities (1)
- priority (1)
- prize (1)
- profile (1)
- proposal (1)
- proposed (1)
- proud (1)
- provider (1)
- public (1)
- public comment (1)
- public comment period (1)
- public list (1)
- quant (1)
- quant self (1)
- quantified (1)
- quantified self (1)
- queue length (1)
- quinquennial (1)
- re-validate (1)
- reflection (1)
- regulations (1)
- representatives (1)
- required (1)
- requirement (1)
- researchers (1)
- reseller (1)
- revalidate (1)
- revenue (1)
- revoke (1)
- revoked (1)
- rights (1)
- rivals (1)
- roadblock (1)
- roadmap (1)
- rsa conference (1)
- sales (1)
- salted (1)
- savings (1)
- scalability (1)
- season (1)
- security software (1)
- select (1)
- selected (1)
- selection (1)
- self-driving (1)
- self-driving car (1)
- senate (1)
- senators (1)
- server (1)
- servers (1)
- silver (1)
- simplify (1)
- smart cars (1)
- smart home (1)
- smart toilet (1)
- smartwatch (1)
- sole source provider (1)
- sole-source (1)
- speak (1)
- speaking session (1)
- specialization (1)
- stand for (1)
- standards (1)
- start-up (1)
- state (1)
- stealth mode (1)
- stigma (1)
- story (1)
- strategy (1)
- success (1)
- summer (1)
- sunet (1)
- sunset date (1)
- sunsetted (1)
- symposium (1)
- talk (1)
- tech (1)
- technical (1)
- term (1)
- terminology (1)
- terms (1)
- threat detection (1)
- threats (1)
- toilet (1)
- top gun (1)
- training (1)
- trophy (1)
- unicorn (1)
- use cases (1)
- value (1)
- vendors (1)
- website (1)
- whining (1)
- whistleblower (1)
- whistleblowing (1)
- wifi (1)
- wrap (1)
- wrap-up (1)